winchester gun parts, gun parts, stocks, buttplates

Model 54 Winchester

 Images can be enlarged by clicking them

Introduction | I. Models | II. Variations | III. Condition
Model 54 (Outline) | Gun Parts Diagram

Condition of Firearms

Step 3: Determine the Condition of firearm

You will find many ways of describing the condition of firearms -- some references use percentages while some just use descriptive words.  All methods are somewhat subjective.  For your purpose, read the descriptions of the categories carefully and then select the one that best fits the gun you are appraising.  Since we are dealing only with old guns, we will almost use one of the following:  Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, and Poor. 

New In Box (NIB):  The gun is in the original sale box. All original parts, including sights and minor parts are brand new.  The finish of both metal and wood is original and at 100%.  The lettering is sharp and clear and any design on the metal and wood is sharp and clear.  There should also be documentation available on the gun.  (Note that this will be a very unusual category, as not many Model 63 Winchesters can be found today with original box and sales tags - be careful if you do as there are a number of fakes presently on the market).


Excellent:  The gun has all original parts, including sights and any additional factory add-on parts.  The finish of both metal and wood is original and at 90% or better.  The lettering is sharp and clear and any design on the metal and wood is sharp and clear.  There may be minor marks in the wood, but they are few and the finish is original and excellent.  The metal may show some slight wear at the muzzle or sharp edges.  The bore is very good with rifling prominent. 


Very Good: A "very good" gun is in perfect working condition with no appreciable wear on working surfaces, no corrosion or pitting and only very minor scratches.  All original parts with at least 80% of the original finish.  Original metal surfaces are smooth.  Lettering and designs are clear.  Wood may be slightly scratched or bruised.  There may be some very minor repairs or alterations. 


Good:  Some minor replacement parts are acceptable, but all parts must be working.  The metal may be  smoothly rusted or lightly pitted in places, and the gun may be cleaned, although at least 50% of the original factory finish must be evident.  Lettering and design is legible, and the wood may be refinished, scratched, bruised, or minor cracks repaired.  Gun is in good and safe working order.  The bore may have some wear and pitting. 


Fair:  Some major parts may be replaced.  There may be some minor parts missing.  Some rust on the metal and/or lightly pitted.  The gun may have been vigorously cleaned or re-blued.  Edges of the metal may be rounded and worn, and principal lettering and design may be partly obliterated.  Wood is scratched, bruised, cracked or repaired.  In safe working order or easily repaired so that the gun is restored to working order.  If your gun has had major repairs, alterations or non-factory additions or a recent refinishing, it is graded in this class.


Poor: Major and minor parts replaced and there may be major parts that require extensive restoration.  Metal may be deeply pitted and the principal lettering and design is obliterated.  Wood may be badly scratched, bruised, cracked or broken.  The gun may be mechanically inoperative.  A poor gun is generally not desired by collectors, although there may be some value in the parts.  A poor gun may make a very nice "wall hanger."

Enter Condition of your gun in the column to the right 



Continue to Valuation of  Gun

Click images to enlarge

Introduction | Models | Variations | Condition | Model 54 Outline of Features | Gun Parts